| 1st TEAM | ||
| Player | Class | School |
| Kayleigh Buckner | Senior | Bellevue |
| Kaitlan Drennen | Senior | Bellevue |
| Bridget Wolfe | Senior | Bellevue |
| Katie Yantz | Senior | Bellevue |
| Elizabeth Miller | Sophomore | Tiffin Columbian |
| Aja Hall | Junior | Fostoria |
| Taylor Newlove | Junior | Fostoria |
| Keri Seel | Senior | Fostoria |
| Lisa Patusky | Junior | Norwalk |
| Amanda Reamer | Senior | Norwalk |
| Courtney Eberole | Senior | Shelby |
| Nici Fluharty | Junior | Willard |
2009 All-NOL League Selections- Softball
| 2nd TEAM | ||
| Player | Class | School |
| Carli Bogard | Junior | Tiffin Columbian |
| Rachel Reamer | Sophomore | Tiffin Columbian |
| Allyson Beechum | Sophomore | Fostoria |
| Peyton Feeney | Junior | Galion |
| Audrey Ross | Senior | Norwalk |
| Allie Cox | Sophomore | Upper Sandusky |
| Kayla Frey | Junior | Upper Sandusky |
| Lindsey Kessler | Sophomore | Upper Sandusky |
| Logan Meddings | Sophomore | Upper Sandusky |
| Shayleen Wood | Sophomore | Upper Sandusky |
| Liz Fried | Sophomore | Willard |
| Kailey Kimble | Senior | Willard |
| HONORABLE MENTION | ||
| Player | Class | School |
| Sarah Dumas | Junior | Bellevue |
| Erika Jordan | Junior | Bellevue |
| Morgan Anway | Sophomore | Tiffin Columbian |
| Genee Keels | Junior | Fostoria |
| Melanie Nye | Juniior | Fostoria |
| Raina White | Sophomore | Fostoria |
| Amy Cullen | Junior | Galion |
| Katie May | Senior | Norwalk |
| Elle McGue | Senior | Norwalk |
| Nicole Harding | Senior | Shelby |
| Tasha Seymour | Sophomore | Shelby |
| Katie Wetherell | Senior | Upper Sandusky |
| Erika Chuburko | Junior | Willard |
| Sam Kamann | Senior | Willard |
© 2009
TiffinOhioSports.com
TiffinOhioSports.com
